one tree hill
“Hey tutor girl.” Brooke said with a knowing smirk which turned Haley’s legs to jelly.
“H, hey.” Haley stammered with a blush, unable to look Brooke in the eye, partly because she was embarrassed… and partly because Brooke Davis was standing in the doorway of Peyton Sawyer’s house completely naked.
There was a few seconds of sound which felt like an eternity to Haley as she waited politely to be invited in, the whole time wishing either the ground would open up and swallow her or Brooke would pull her inside and fuck her brains out. Ideally the latter although Haley would have probably taken the former over just standing there like an idiot.
“You wanna come in?” Brooke finally asked, Haley rushing past her the moment she stood back, allowing Brooke to shut and lock the door behind them. There was another few seconds of silence, during which Brooke happily notice that Haley couldn’t keep her eyes off of her, a fact which made Brooke smile, “See something you like tutor girl?”
Haley blushed, her eyes now drifting down to Brooke’s feet.
“I’ll take that as a yes.” Brooke smirked, before pretending to look thoughtful, “But I guess the real question is, what is innocent little tutor girl doing here? Did she come to study? Maybe teach me or Peyton something? Or did tutor girl come to get tutored?”
Before Brooke could continue her teasing Haley looked up at her, and then totally taking Brooke off guard, quickly closed the distance between them and kissed her roughly on the lips.
Brooke was too shocked to react for a few seconds, then she happily kissed back, more happily surprised than shocked a short while later when Haley pushed her tongue into her welcoming mouth.
The kiss lasted for several minutes, and then while she still had her nerve Haley broke it and gasped, “Do whatever you want with me.”
“Be careful tutor girl, I might just take you up on that offer.” Brooke smirked.
“Please do.” Haley said, “I… I can’t stop thinking about you. And Peyton. I can’t stop thinking about the two of you together. Or the thought of you two fucking me. And I… I want it so bad. Please Brooke, fuck me. I’ll do anything.”
Brooke was blown away by Haley’s confession. She had hoped to seduce her friend into bed, but she hadn’t expected to be so successful so quickly. Damn, she was good.
Unable to resist pushing Haley a little Brooke gave her friend a lustful look, leant forward and then whispered in her ear, “Anything?”
“Anything.” Haley gasped, already unbelievably turned on just from one kiss and being so close to the other girl.
“So… you’re going to be a good little lesbian fuck toy for me and Peyton?” Brooke pushed.
“Yes.” Haley said softly, then adding something she’d never imagined herself saying, “I’ll… I’ll be a good little lesbian fuck toy.”
Again Brooke was surprised as she had expected Haley to just blush in response. She was still blushing of course, but the look in Haley’s eyes told Brooke that the other girl meant what she just said, which of course just made Brooke want to push her even more.
“Prove it. Strip for me, right here, right now.” Brooke ordered.
Finally it looked like Brooke might have gone too far as Haley really looked apprehensive, “Is… is there anyone else here? Other than Peyton I mean… she is here, isn’t she?”
“Maybe.” Brooke said playfully, however regret it when she saw Haley become even more apprehensive and quickly changed her tune, “And by maybe I mean no. It’s just you, and me, and Peyton… who is a little tied up at the moment.”
“Oh… ok.” Haley said softly, before she slowly removed her clothes, feeling incredibly awkward and un-sexy despite Brooke’s lustful looks at her.
Once Haley was naked Brooke wordlessly took her by the hand and guided her into the house, allowing Haley to get a good look at her ass as they walked up the stairs and headed into Peyton’s room.
Haley was a little surprised to see that Peyton was literally a little tied up at the moment, her hands and feet restrained by rope which was interned tied to each corner of the bed, the blonde position sideways on the bed so that her naked body was one perfect display as the two brunettes walked in. As her eyes travelled over her friend’s beautiful body, particularly resting on her pussy which was easily accessible thanks to the position, Haley suppose she shouldn’t have been surprised given what she knew about Brooke Davis and what she had recently learnt about the other brunette’s relationship with her BFF.
Turning to that other brunette Haley found something much less surprising, in fact not also, that being there was a huge smile on Brooke’s face.
Just then Haley heard Peyton’s voice, “You came.”
“Y, yes.” Haley stammered, stating the obvious.
“And we’re glad you did.” Brooke said, again pushing things a bit by gently wrapping her arms around Haley’s stomach and pressing her body into the other girl. Haley gasped as Brooke’s rock hard nipples dug into her back and Brooke’s wet pussy pressed against her ass, but offered no resistance. Pushing things a little further still Brooke gave Haley’s neck a few gentle kisses, and then lightly nibbled on her earlobe before whispering in her ear, “I hope the light bondage doesn’t freak you out. We haven’t gone very far with it, like whips or anything, but it’s a real turn on to have someone else completely at your mercy.”
Haley didn’t think you needed to tie someone up to have them completely at your mercy, after all that was exactly the situation she felt she was in with Brooke. She would have said as much if Brooke’s soft lips and gently nipping teeth weren’t attacking her neck and thus turning her entire body into a big bowl of jelly.
Brooke continued her teasing from while, her eyes occasionally drifting to Peyton who was watching them intently, obviously wishing she could join in but almost just as happy to watch.
It was extremely tempting for Brooke to just have her way with Haley right then and there with Peyton watching.
Brooke was pretty sure both girls would be happy for her to do so, but as much as she wanted to fuck Haley as her girlfriend watched what Brooke really wanted was for all three of them to have some fun. What she really wanted was an all girl threesome, and what Brooke Davis wanted Brooke Davis got.
She had to be subtle about it though, which was why Brooke took baby steps. First she slipped her hands round to play with Haley’s breasts, cupping them and tweaking her nipples until they were as hard as Brooke’s were. Then she slid a hand down to play with Haley’s pussy lips, sliding her fingertips up and down for several moments until Haley whimpered, “Please Brooke… fuck me.”
Not wanting to disappoint Brooke shoved two fingers inside Haley’s needy cunt, the other brunette crying out joyfully as her pussy was first invaded and then gently fucked by the skilled fingers of another girl.
The whole time her fingers had been working on tutor girl Brooke had been kissing and nipping Haley’s neck and earlobe. When she began finger fucking the other girl Brooke began to grind herself against Haley’s soft but firm little ass, once again happily surprised when Haley reacted favourably, this time grinding her ass back into Brooke’s pussy which only encouraged Brooke to fuck Haley harder.
When Brooke sense that Haley was getting close she finally whispered in her ear, “You know, if the bondage bothers you, we can untie her… but I was having a lot of fun teasing her before you arrived. I was just about to give her what she wanted too. Maybe you could watch. Or… maybe you could give her what she wants.”
Haley bit her lip. Even though she couldn’t have imagined it a week ago she wanted too. She… she wanted to give Peyton what she wanted… to lick Peyton’s pussy, but first she needed something.
“O… ok, just, just make me cum first. Ok?” Haley whimpered.
“Hm… I don’t know. I really love fucking you, and I loved making you cum before, but how do I know you won’t run out the door the moment I let you cum?” Brooke question.
“I won’t. I promise. I… I’ll, I’ll lick Peyton’s pussy. I’ll lick your pussy. I’ll do whatever you want, just please make me cum.” Haley begged.
Brooke looked thoughtful for a moment, then turned her attention to her girlfriend, “What do you think Peyton? Should I let her cum?”
“Yes.” Peyton replied immediately, “Make her cum. Fuck her and make her cum.”
Brooke grinned, nibbled on Haley’s ear again, and said, “Well, you have Peyton’s vote… and it is really hard to resist making you cum, so how about this… I’ll let you cum, if you say… you want to be a little lesbian fuck toy.”
“I want to be a little lesbian fuck toy.” Haley quickly said.
“You want to eat pussy.” Brooke said, gently beginning to increase the speed of her finger thrusting.
“I, ohhhh, I want to eat pussy.” Haley parroted.
“You want to go down on me and Peyton.” Brooke said teasingly as she continued to increase the pace of the finger fucking.
“I want, ahhhh, I want to go down on you and Peyton.” Haley said, beginning to hump back against the invading fingers.
“You want to get fucked by me and Peyton.” Brooke continued to tease as she began really hammering Haley’s honey hole with her fingers.
“I, mmmmmm, I want to get fucked by you and Peyton.” Haley moaned, and then added of her own accord, “I want you and Peyton to fuck me. Oh, fuck me, ah, fuck me just like that, ooooooohhhhhhh, harder, ooooooohhhhhhh.”
“Tell me you want to cum for me!” Brooke demanded, all teasing gone from her voice as she fucked her friend hard.
“Yeeeeessssss! Fuuuuuccccckkkkk meeeeeee! Fuck me hard and make me cum! Oh, I wanna cum for you Brooke Davis. I wanna cum for another girl.” Haley whimpered and moaned, “Ooooohhhhhh Gooooooddddd, I want to cum for you, I want to cum from getting fucked by another girl, mmmmmmmm, I want to… I want to cuuuuuuummmmmmmmm!”
Haley’s next words were completely incoherent as Brooke fucked her to an orgasm stronger than any her husband Nathan had ever given her. It made her body quiver and her legs turned to jelly, Brooke’s surprisingly strong grip being the only thing that kept Haley on her feet, which was extra impressive considering Brooke fucked Haley right through her orgasm, keeping her friend on her high for as long as possible with continuous hard thrusts before slowly bringing her down from it by gradually slowing the pace.
As she began bringing Haley down from her high Brooke began gently kissing the other girl’s neck. When she was sure Haley had recovered Brooke gently nipped at her friend’s earlobe and then whispered in her ear, “Well done tutor girl. You just came for me like a good little lesbian fuck toy. But the question is, do you want me to play with you some more, or are you ready to return the favour?”
There was a moment’s pause and then Haley quickly turned around in Brooke’s arms and shoved her tongue down the other girl’s throat. If this wasn’t shocking enough innocent little Haley James Scott began gently moving Brooke Davis backwards and slightly sideways, leaving Brooke with barely enough time to kiss back let alone figure out what Haley was trying to do. However Brooke trusted Haley and allowed herself to be moved and then pushed backwards, relieved that she landed in a chair and thus proving her trust was well founded.
About a second after Brooke’s ass landed on the chair Haley was kneeling between her thighs with her face buried in Brooke’s cleavage.
It wasn’t the area Brooke had expected, but then again until a few seconds ago she hadn’t expected Haley to be so aggressive. The aggression was an incredible turn on considering Haley was normally so meek, Brooke loving the fact that her friend wasted no time in latching on to her nipples and beginning to suck on them greedily.
“Haley.” Brooke moaned huskily, gently pressing the other brunette’s head down onto her breast.
At the sound of her name Haley sucked harder and even brought her hands into the mix, at first just cupping Brooke’s tits, but quickly moving on to squeezing them affectionately and then tweaking whichever nipple she wasn’t sucking on with which ever available hand.
With such positive results Brooke could only continue moaning Haley’s name which resulted in a tongue beginning to circle and flick her nipples in between sucks, Haley becoming rougher and rougher until just as suddenly as she began she stopped, her lips travelling downwards and not stopping until she reached her destination. Even then she didn’t stop, Haley’s tongue immediately shooting out of her mouth and sliding over the soft, wet flesh in front of her, obviously not interested in savouring the moment.
However Brooke savoured the moment as much as she possibly could, at the moment innocent, and honestly a little dorky, Haley James Scott licked her first pussy. For the first time Haley James Scott was going down on another girl, the girl in question just happening to be the notorious Brooke Davis… who despite being Tree Hill’s poster girl for sex found herself bold over by this moment.
“Oh God tutor girl… Haley, mmmmmmmm, Hales, oooooooohhhhhhhh…” Brooke moaned, repeating Haley’s name and her nicknames over and over again as her friend lapped at her pussy like a hungry kitty with a saucer of milk.
Haley didn’t have Peyton’s experience but she made up for it with surprising eagerness which only seemed to increase with every lick. Eventually Haley even began to experiment with how she licked, Brooke crying out joyfully as she felt Haley beginning to slide her tongue around her pussy lips as well as up and down them. Shortly after this Brooke cried out joyfully again as Haley began licking her clit, just a few gentle laps at first as her tongue was making her way round her pussy, and then with longer, firmer strokes.
As Haley really started to get the hang of licking pussy Brooke was finding it increasingly difficult to keep her mouth shut. She loved talking dirty during sex, but she didn’t want to break Haley’s concentration or worse scare her off. So after it became clear she could no longer trust her mouth Brooke started biting down hard on her lip to keep the naughty words from coming out. It just about worked, but only because Brooke was biting almost hard enough to draw blood.
Still wanting to encourage her friend Brooke reached down and began gently stroking Haley’s hair affectionately, at first subtlely trying to move the other girl’s position so she was licking in certain places, and then not so subtlely as Brooke began to get very used to the feeling of Haley’s tongue against her entrance and her clit.
Ironically as she became used to having Haley’s tongue in those places Brooke found she could no longer control her own tongue, “Oooooohhhhhh yeeeessssss, oh Hales, oh my God, fuck, fuck me, yes, mmmmmmmmm, fuck me! Fuck me tutor girl! Mmmmmmmm, lick my pussy. Yes, lick my pussy just like that you little slut. Oooooooh, yeah, lick my pussy you naughty little cunt lapping dyke.”
To Brooke’s delight not only did Haley only keep gently lapping her snatch, but she slowly began to increase the force of her licks.
Taking this as a sign that she could say whatever she wanted Brooke gleefully let loose with the dirty talk, “Mmmmmmm, that’s it you carpet munching little queer girl, eat my fucking pussy! Fuck, get your cute little lesbian face as deep in my fucking cunt as you can! Ohhhhhhh fuck yeah, you like this don’t you, you nasty little muff diver! Oooooooooh, you like me talking dirty to you while you’ve got your pretty little face buried between my thighs? Yes you do, mmmmmmm, yeah, oh, innocent little tutor girl loves being told what a slut she is, while she’s lapping away at a nice juicy pussy like the lesbo ho she is. Aaaaaah fuck, no, not just a slut or a ho, mmmmmmm, tutor girl is a little lesbian fuck toy. Tutor girl is my little lesbian fuck toy. Isn’t that right Hales?”
“Yes, I’m your little lesbian fuck toy Brooke. I’m Brooke Davis’s little lesbian fuck toy.” Haley said submissively, only briefly moving away from Brooke’s cunt to deliver this message before going right back to work on the wet love hole in front of her.
“And you’re Peyton’s little lesbian fuck toy too aren’t you?” Brooke grinned as she glanced over at Peyton, and then frowned as Haley just nodded in response, “Tell her tutor girl. Tell my girlfriend what you are.”
Wasting no time Haley pulled her face out from between Brooke’s legs to look behind her at the blonde, “I’m Peyton Sawyer’s little lesbian fuck toy. I’m Peyton Sawyer’s and Brooke Davis’s little lesbian fuck toy.”
“Good girl, ohhhhhh, good little lesbian fuck toy. You can go back to licking my pussy now.” Brooke told her friend, guessing Haley would’ve probably done so anyway, the only difference being that after her words Haley blushed a little before burying her face back in Brooke’s twat. Grinning and stroking Haley’s hair again Brooke looked over at Peyton and said, “Mmmmmm, Hales looks so good between my thighs, don’t you think P Sawyer?”
“Uh-huh.” Peyton replied nonchalantly, her focus still very much on Haley.
Peyton was just as surprised as Brooke how quickly and easily it had been to get innocent little married girl Haley James Scott on her knees licking pussy. Also just like her girlfriend Peyton was enjoying it, although not nearly as much. This was mainly because she was reaping the benefits of Haley’s tongue, which if Brooke’s moans were anything to go by was doing a great job, but honestly Peyton was feeling a little jealous.
This was something she’d agreed to do, and it was beyond hot to see her sweet, innocent friend with her head in between her girlfriend’s legs, but at the same time Brooke was her girlfriend. Hers. So the jealousy was a natural reaction, one which Peyton couldn’t really help, or ignore. But she knew Brooke loved her and this was just a little meaningless sex. Well, not meaningless. More like, educational sex. She and Brooke were tutoring tutor girl, showing her there was more than just the ‘normal’ type of sex Nathan Scott had to offer. Or at least they would if Brooke ever untied her.
Of course Peyton knew that her girlfriend had no intention of untying her any time soon, not when Brooke had Haley James Scott’s mouth and tongue all to herself. So Peyton just watched and enjoyed it the show which was in front of her and tried not to think about how much she’d like to join it.
“Fuuuuuuccccccccckkkkkkk yeeeeeesssssss yoooooouuuuuu fuuuuuuccccccccckkkkkkkiiiiiiinnnnnnggggggg dyyyyykkkkeeeee!” Brooke screamed as Haley suddenly pushed her tongue inside her cunt. After this initial reaction the pleasure didn’t necessarily decrease but Brooke recovered enough of her wits to groan, “Yeeeeesssss! Fuck me you nasty little dyke bitch! Fuck my pussy with your little lezzie tongue! Oh, mmmmmmmmm, yes, tongue fuck me like the good little lesbian fuck toy you are Haley. Tongue fuck me good. Mmmmmmmm, fuck yeah, just like that, ohhhhhhh, fuck! Ha, if only your husband could see you now.”
These last words, more than any other Brooke had used, cut through Haley like a knife. They made her imagine what would happen if Nathan stumbled across her in between Brooke’s thighs in the same way she had found Peyton going down on Brooke. She could just picture the look on his face. The betrayal. Oh, how she’d rather the ground swallow her up than for that to ever happen.
Of course Haley was betraying him right now. She was cheating on him. She had cheated on him before with the same woman she had been frantically tongue fucking up until a few moments, and even as these horrifying thoughts went through her body she ached to continue the tongue fucking. But it was more than that. She needed too. Haley needed to keep fucking Brooke Davis, so much so that after only a few seconds of thinking about her husband Haley couldn’t stop herself from beginning to thrust her tongue in and out of Brooke’s pussy again, which of course only had Brooke grinning in triumph.
“Oh, you like that, don’t you tutor girl? The thought of your husband seeing you like this? Him seeing your face in between my legs. Licking my pussy. Fucking it with your tongue. I wonder what he’d think?” Brooke questioned thoughtfully, pausing for a few moments to let Haley’s thoughts run wild before adding, “I bet he’d love it. Mmmmmmm, I bet he’d just love to watch his innocent little wife tongue fuck another girl. What guy wouldn’t? Ha, mmmmmmmm, bet he’d even, oh, ask to join us. But we won’t let him. Ohhhhh, no, just you Hales. He can watch us fuck if he asks real nicely, ooooooohhhhhhhh and I bet you’d love that wouldn’t you? Mmmmmmmm, that way you wouldn’t have to feel so bad about loving my pussy so much. But you shouldn’t feel bad Hales, mmmmmmm, it’s not your fault you’re a cunt craving whore who can’t keep her mouth and tongue to herself. No, you clearly need to eat pussy. Mmmmmmm, yeeeeesssss, well go ahead, eat my pussy you fucking dyke! Oooooooohhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeessssssss! Oh fuck! FUCK! EAT ME YOU FUCKING LESBIAN WHORE! FUCKING EAT MY FUCKING PUSSY! FUUUUUUCCCCCCKKKKKK!”
At this point Haley had realised the only way she was going to get Brooke to shut up was to fuck her to a screaming orgasm. Or at least that was the only thing Haley could think of in that moment, and maybe if she was lucky she could fuck Brooke so hard she’d be too overwhelmed by pleasure to be able to keep talking about Nathan, or at least not coherently.
It took a while and a lot of effort on Haley’s part but when she began curling her tongue to attack the other girl’s G-spot Haley finally achieved her goal of turning Brooke Davis into an incoherent babbling mess.
Unfortunately Haley couldn’t quite shake Brooke’s words and now she had this picture of her husband cheering her on as she tongue fucked another girl to orgasm. Nathan was far too straitlaced for anything like that, but having a fantasy version of him happily encouraging her to eat pussy was oddly comforting. It helped that fantasy version and had a raging hard on that promised Haley a nice hard fucking, and thanks to Brooke’s sensual moans, the words of the other brunette, and most of all the sheer thrill of eating pussy had Haley feeling like she could cum just from going down on Brooke Davis.
While Haley didn’t cum even when she started humping the floor like a bitch in heat Brooke came almost violently, her screams almost deafening the other two girls as she thrashed around in her seat. As a result it was difficult for Haley to remain in place but somehow she did, and she even managed to make Brooke cum a few more times, twice with two of her fingers pumping in and out of the other brunette as she sucked on her clit, and one more time after that as she was greedily sucking the girl cum out of her cunt.
Just when Haley was done swallowing down the latest batch of girl cum Brooke reached down with both hands, grabbed hold of her hair and pulled her back roughly. Haley cried out in protest, partly because of the pain of having her hair pulled, but mostly because she was being denied Brooke’s sweet pussy. The kiss Brooke gave her somewhat made up for it, but Haley still wished she was back in between Brooke’s thighs, at least until she heard what the other brunette had to say next.
“Wow tutor girl, that was amazing.” Brooke said huskily after she pulled away from Haley’s lips and licked her own, getting another taste of her own pussy juice which was covering the whole of Haley’s pretty little face as well as lingering inside her mouth, “Are you sure you’ve never eaten pussy before?”
“I, I’m… I’m sure.” Haley stammered, her old self coming back as a huge blush filled her cheeks, “I’ve never done that before.”
“Well you should definitely do it a lot from now on. That pretty little mouth of yours shouldn’t go to waste on just one cock.” Brooke said, reaching out to slide her fingers slowly down her friend’s stomach, obviously building the anticipation as Haley’s mouth opened in a silent cry which turned into a very loud moan as those fingers reached Haley’s wet pussy and began gently sliding over the soft flesh, “And this yummy little pussy shouldn’t go to waste on just one man either. Especially not such a selfish dick as Nathan.”
“He’s, ohhhhhh, he’s not selfish.” Haley moaned, but lost her train of thought when Brooke’s fingers suddenly slammed inside of her causing her to cry out joyfully.
“Maybe not anymore, but can you honestly say that he can lick your pussy like I can? That his cock makes you feel as good as my tongue? That he can make you cum like I can?” Brooke asked, smirking as she gave Haley a little chance to respond, the other girl only blushing and lowering her head before lifting it again and crying out happily as Brooke began finger fucking her again, “Didn’t think so… well trust me, I know a girl who can make you cum just as hard with her tongue as I can, a girl who deserves to taste your yummy little cunt. So be a good little lesbian fuck toy and go and sit on my girlfriend’s face. Shove your wet little pussy in her face and feed her cunt hungry dyke mouth your yummy girl juices directly from the source.”
“Brooke I… I… I’ve never done that before.” Haley said, blushing again despite the fact she was being fucked by another girl and should have really been beyond embarrassment.
“Really?” Brooke said, sounding amused and intrigued, “Never?”
“N, no.” Haley blushed.
“Huh.” Brooke frowned, “Nathan’s become quite the prude… unless, you’re the prude.”
“Well, I, I… I just always thought it would be weird.” Haley blushed even more.
“Oh it’s so not.” Brooke said before moving in closer to whisper in Haley’s ear, “Here, let me show you. Or should I say, let Peyton show you.”
Giggling softly Brooke finally removed her fingers from inside of Haley’s cunt and used her other hand to grab hold of her friend’s hand and guide her over to where Peyton was still tied up. Then she literally gave Haley a friendly little push in the right direction.
Looking incredibly unsure of herself Haley crawled onto the bed, awkwardly and slowly climbing over Peyton’s body, the whole time desperately trying not to step on her friend. So when she managed to get into position kneeling above Peyton’s head Haley felt weird but powerful sense of pride. However that weird but powerful sense of pride was quickly taken away from her when she heard Brooke call out, “No, the other way. Turn so you’re facing her pussy.”
Haley grumbled softly as she awkwardly turned around, quickly apologising every time she tread on Peyton as she got into the position Brooke wanted her in.
“Very good.” Brooke said encouragingly as she got into position kneeling beside Haley, gently kissing the other girl’s neck before whispering in her ear, “Now slowly lower yourself down until your pretty little lezzie pussy is pressed against Peyton’s lips. Make sure not to relax your weight down on top of her and smother her with your cunt… at least not yet.”
These words made Haley blush but she obeyed them, lowering herself down with a quickness that made a lazy snail look like a racing car at top speed, the whole time carefully studying every slow movement she was making.
Brooke and Peyton found this both incredibly endearing and slightly annoying. Endearing because of how much Haley seemed worried and nervous about hurting Peyton and the situation in general, annoying because they both wanted the real fun to start again, especially Peyton.
The last thing Peyton wanted to do was to selfishly push her nervous friend but she had been forced to watch from the sidelines as both the other two girls had cum, the whole time wishing to be part of it. Sure, Peyton wanted to cum but Brooke could be a real clit tease so Peyton was used to being cruelly kept on the edge for a very long time. So just the opportunity to taste Haley was more than enough to make Peyton’s mouth water in anticipation.
Unfortunately Peyton was made to wait for what felt like an eternity. Fortunately the waiting eventually ended, and when it finally did and Peyton felt Haley’s pussy lips pressing against her mouth she didn’t hesitate, the blonde’s tongue shooting out to slide over her friend’s wet cunt.
Haley cried out joyfully, her body lifting ever so slightly at the sudden attack of pleasure. Peyton followed, the blonde jerking her head upwards so she could give the other girl’s pussy another lick, and then another, and then another, and then another.
Gently, and probably unknowingly, Haley bounced up and down for a few long moments, never moving out of reach of Peyton’s eagerly lapping tongue. Then Haley seemed to settle down, resting gently against Peyton’s face and surrendering to the pussy licking the blonde’s tongue was giving her.
Peyton had been in this position with Brooke sitting on her face quite a lot recently and she had grown to love it. To be almost smothered in the smell and taste of Brooke Davis was like heaven to Peyton, and while this and any other experience could only be second best with a girl who she wasn’t in love with, this still mark something very important, and very hot for her.
This confirmed Peyton wasn’t just gay for Brooke. She hadn’t really thought she was, but Peyton hadn’t known for sure until the moment she tasted Haley’s sweet pussy. Of course Peyton still didn’t know for sure whether she was bisexual or if any previous interest in guys like Lucas and Nathan were just a result of her desperately trying to stay in the closet and she was in fact a complete and total dyke. In this moment she was leaning towards the latter, but Peyton didn’t want to concentrate on her own sexuality as much as she wanted to concentrate on the task at hand, namely licking Haley’s pretty little pussy.
While part of Haley had been trying to convince herself she might just be gay for Brooke and Peyton it was pretty much a losing argument. Sure, she was more attracted to them than any other girls, but the first time she had seen them together had awoken something inside Haley she didn’t know was there, her lesbian side. It was pretty hard to deny she had one at this point, especially as she was moaning in pleasure from the feeling of the second ever girl to lick her pussy.
So this pretty much confirmed Haley was at least bi too, and, like Peyton, Haley couldn’t help wonder if she had been fooling herself all this time with her marriage to Nathan and supposedly attraction to other boys all just to hide the fact that she was gay.
Luckily Haley was rescued from these thoughts by a rough feeling of pressure on her right nipple, the sensation causing her to gasp out and focus on a grinning Brooke Davis, “You like it, huh tutor girl? You like sitting on my girlfriend’s face? Feeding her your yummy dyke pussy?”
Haley moaned, blushed and nodded her head as Brooke started gently playing with her nipple.
“Yeahhhh, I knew you would. I knew a little lezzie slut like you would just love this.” Brooke said lustfully, reaching out to grab the other nipple so she could play with that too, “Riding another girl’s face, rubbing your cunt all over her as she fucks you, covering her in your hot lezzie cream… and soon you’re going to cover her in your dyke cum, aren’t you? Yeah, you’re going to cover my girlfriend’s pretty face in your dyke cum, and I’m going to help you.”
With that Brooke lowered her head and latched her mouth onto one of Haley’s tits, roughly suckling on the nipple for a few moments before moving to the other. This unsurprisingly caused Haley to moan even more, her volume only increasing when Peyton, probably because of what Brooke was doing, wrapped her lips around Haley’s pussy and began gently sucking.
The sensations of two knowing, female mouths worshipping her body was almost too much to bear. Then when tongues were added to the mix, Brooke using hers to swirl around Haley’s nipples, and then Peyton sliding hers deep into Haley’s pussy it became too much to bear.
“Ohhhhhh, ooooooooohhhhhhhhh, I’m going to cuuuuuuummmmmmm!” Haley moaned briefly before crying out in pain as Brooke roughly twisted her nipples.
“BEG!” Brooke growled, “Beg for permission to cum you dirty little lesbo slut!”
“Please, please, please can I cum? Please Brooke, mmmmmm, I need. I need to cum. Ohhhhhh please let me cum.” Haley quickly begged, “Your little lesbian fuck toy needs to cum so bad Brooke, ooooooh mmmmmmm, please let your little lesbian fuck toy cum.”
“Beg Peyton too. Make sure she knows how much you want her to make you cum.” Brooke demanded, now once again playing with Haley’s nipples gently.
“Peyton, Peyton please, make me cum.” Haley quickly begged, searching her brain for whatever she thought the other two girls wanted to hear, “I want to make me cum so bad. I, mmmmmmmm, I, I… I want another girl to make me cum. I, oh, I really want another girl to make me cum, mmmmmmm, prove I’m nothing but a slutty little dyke so I can be a good little lesbian fuck toy for you and Brooke. Please, please make me cum, please maaaakkkkkeeee meeeeeee cuuuuummmmmmm, oh please!”
“Ok Peyton, you can make her cum, but just once!” Brooke said firmly before pressing her lips to Haley’s, swallowing the other girl’s screams as Peyton made her cum.
Haley had been on the edge for so long that all it took was one thrust of Peyton’s tongue to make the tutor cum, Haley shaking wildly in Brooke’s arms as she covered Peyton’s face in girl cum. Of course Peyton did her best to swallow as much of the yummy liquid as she could, but there was just so much of it, and the way Haley was shaking made her pussy rub against Peyton’s in a way which made sure the blonde was practically drowned in sweet girly cream.
To enhance Haley’s orgasm Brooke squeezed roughly on her friend’s nipple with her thumb and index finger while the rest of her fingers massaged the soft flesh of Haley’s tits. When she sensed that Haley was coming down from her high Brooke broke the lip lock, quickly kissed her way down her friend’s body, undid Peyton’s handcuffs and then whispered, “Don’t make her cum again until I make you cum.”
The moment she finished speaking Brooke began to kiss her way down Peyton’s body, pausing for a little while to lick, suck and gently massage her girlfriend’s boobs, then slowly kissing down the blonde’s flat stomach to the juicy little treat in between her legs.
Once she reached her destination Brooke didn’t hesitate in sliding her tongue out of her mouth and over the soaking wet lips of Peyton’s pussy. Nor did Brooke hesitate in repeating the action, the cheerleader captain beginning to gently lick her fellow cheerleader’s cunt while above her another member of her squad writhed happily on the blonde cheerleader’s face.
Brooke smiled with pride as she heard Haley moan, “Ooooooooooohhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeessssssss lick me. Lick my pussy. Oh Peyton. Oh, mmmmmmmmm, lick my hot lesbian cunt! Ooooooooh Goooooodddddd Peyton, make me cover your pretty face in my lesbian cum again. Oh please, mmmmmmmm, make me cum like a little lesbian slut. Oh God, I’m a lesbian, I’m a lesbian for you and your tongue Peyton, mmmmmmmm, oooooooh, I’m your little lesbian fuck toy, ohhhhhhhhhh, fuck me, fuck me with your tongue, mmmmmmmm, fuck my naughty little dyke cunt with your hot lesbian tongue, oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhh myyyyyyyy Gooooooddddddddd!”
Innocent little tutor girl Haley James Scott would have probably never, ever used such foul language if it wasn’t for Brooke Davis. She definitely wouldn’t be riding another girl’s face like a shameless lezzie slut either, so it was safe to say at this point Brooke had successfully corrupted the once shy geeky girl. But while it was easy for Brooke to get lost in that triumph she had a job to do, and that was the greatest job she’d ever had, giving the girl she loved pleasure.
So Brooke did her best to block out Haley’s moans and concentrate on licking Peyton’s pussy. However as she began concentrating on that simply licking at the soft wet lips wasn’t enough. She needed to give Peyton more pleasure, and she needed more of her girlfriend’s delicious pussy juice. Luckily Brooke knew how to get what she needed.
Peyton cried out joyfully into Haley’s pussy as her own pussy was invaded by her girlfriend’s tongue, Brooke thrusting as deep as she could and then beginning to gently tongue fuck the blonde. That gentle tongue fucking quickly turned into Brooke slamming her tongue in and out of Peyton’s cunt as hard and as fast as she could, finally giving Peyton exactly what she wanted.
Before Haley had arrived Brooke had teased Peyton for almost an hour. At the time Peyton had loved it. She had dreams of Brooke making slow, gentle love to her for years and Peyton treasured every single moment of it. But by the end she desperately needed to cum, and while she had enjoyed watching Haley surrendering to Brooke’s seduction and eating Haley’s pussy every moment of it and felt like sexual torture because she needed to cum so bad. And now she was finally getting fucked hard by Brooke’s tongue Peyton knew she wouldn’t last long.
Wanting to make sure Haley came Peyton copied Brooke’s actions and began slamming Haley’s fuck hole with her tongue as hard and as she could, the blonde grabbing a tight hold of the round little butt cheek she had been lovingly fondling ever since she had been uncuffed to make sure Haley didn’t thrash around too much while she was fucking her.
The sudden increase in the power of the tongue fucking had Haley screaming joyfully, “OOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHH FUUUUUUUCCCCCCCKKKKKK YEEEEESSSSSSSS! FUCK ME! OH FUCK ME! FUCK ME PEYTON, FUCK ME HARD! FUCK MY DYKE CUNT WITH YOUR TONGUE! OOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHH MMMMMMMMMMM FUUUUUUUCCCCCCKKKKKK MEEEEEEEEEE! OH FUCK! FUCK MY LEZZIE CUNT, TONGUE FUCK ME. FUCK ME LIKE A DYKE SLUT! OH FUCK ME, FUCK ME, MAKE ME CUM, FUCK ME AND MAKE ME CUM FUCK ME AND MAKE ME CUM FUCK ME AND MAKE ME CUM FUUUUUUUUUCCCCCCCCCCKKKKKKK!”
Haley continued to try and beg Peyton to fuck her but her words dissolved into incoherent gibberish thanks to the mind melting orgasm that rocked her body. That orgasm was quickly followed by another, and another, and another, each one as powerful as the last, her entire world dissolving into nothing but pure ecstasy.
Peyton wasn’t quite so fortunate as even though Brooke easily made her cum she felt compelled to continue fucking Haley. That proved incredibly difficult as thanks to all the buildup Peyton’s first orgasm was so powerful it nearly knocked her unconscious. It definitely succeeded in making her feel like she couldn’t continued fucking Haley even if she wanted too, but even as she was practically gushing girl cum all over Brooke’s face Peyton couldn’t help thinking how the whole point of this little threesome was to fuck Haley so good she wouldn’t be able to stay away from them, wouldn’t be able to stop from becoming their little lesbian fuck toy. A couple of climaxes would have probably done the trick, but Peyton knew if she continued she would be able to bag Haley for sure. So Peyton pushed through the ecstasy she was feeling so she could continue making Haley cum.
While Brooke wasn’t receiving the same amount of pleasure Haley or even Peyton was receiving she was still having a hell of a time. In a way Brooke loved giving her girlfriend pleasure even more than she loved receiving it, and there was no other way Brooke liked giving the girl she loved pleasure more than being in between Peyton’s thighs and eating her sweet pussy. Brooke had always loved giving guys head, but she loved going down on Peyton more. She also preferred swallowing Peyton’s cum, and there was a lot of it, so much so that even after she switched things up so that she was finger fucking Peyton’s cunt while sucking on her clit it wasn’t long before Brooke switch back to the tongue fucking so she could gulp more delicious girl cream down her greedy throat.
Brooke managed to convince herself to switch back and forth between fucking Peyton with her fingers and fucking Peyton with her tongue for a while then came the really difficult task of convincing herself to pull away. That was always a difficult task for Brooke, but considering her own body was burning for attention she was able to convince herself to pull away so she could get ready to fulfil one of her biggest ever fantasies. First however she couldn’t resist moving up and kissing Haley again, the formerly innocent tutor girl not hesitating in passionately returning the kiss.
Even in her barely conscious state Haley knew she was tasting Peyton’s cum and pussy cream on Brooke’s lips. She was tasting the cum and pussy cream of her second ever girl, and she wanted more. Haley wanted to taste Peyton’s cum and pussy cream from the source.
What Haley didn’t know was that Brooke was only too happy to give her the opportunity.
When she broke the kiss Brooke asked huskily, “Did you like that tutor girl? Did you like tasting my girlfriend’s cum on my lips?”
Haley nodded eagerly.
Brooke grinned, “Would you like some more? Would you like some more of my girlfriend’s cum you greedy little dyke?”
Again Haley nodded eagerly.
“Well then here, have some more you greedy little dyke slut!” Brooke growled, grabbing a firm hold of Haley’s hair and pushing her down so her face was in between Peyton’s legs, “Eat my girlfriend’s pussy you little lezzie bitch. Eat that fucking cunt and make my girlfriend cum in your dyke mouth. Make her cum like she’s made you cum. I wanna see you and my girlfriend 69 and make each other cum like the pair of lesbian sluts you are!”
Brooke’s words were unnecessary as the second she pressed Haley’s face down against Peyton’s cunt the innocent little married girl began eating pussy like the rug munching slut Brooke had successfully turned her into.
The sight had Brooke beaming with pride, and tingling with lust, but while she was sure to always keep at least one eye on the show she was sure to set up the next part of the night’s activities before sitting back and watching her girlfriend and her friend fuck each other senseless.
Haley and Peyton weren’t aware of Brooke moving around nearby. They weren’t aware of anything except the delicious pussy juice they were greedily swallowing, the fact that they were using their mouths, tongues and fingers to get as much of that pussy juice as possible, and the pure ecstasy they were feeling as they fucked each other through orgasm after orgasm.
It was like heaven for both of them. There was no guilt over cheating on their partners, no confusion about their sexuality, and none of life’s other little worries. There was only pleasure.
Both girls wished they could have stayed like that forever, of course all good things have to come to an end.
Inevitably exhaustion kicked in, and the more Haley and Peyton found themselves getting tired the more the orgasms seemed to become almost painful. Soon it felt like every part of them was tired and sore, and no matter how hard they tried to continue they just couldn’t.
When Haley finally rolled off Peyton it was a relief for both girls, the two of them laying there in a panting heap for several minutes.
For a moment Haley thought she was going to pass out, then she heard something which gave her the strength to sit up and look over at Peyton lustfully, that being her blonde friend moaning, “Ohhhhh Brooke…”
Apparently Brooke had taken it upon herself to clean up any remaining cum from Peyton’s thighs and pussy, the blonde writhing on the bed as the seductive brunette dipped her tongue inside her cunt a few times before kissing her way up her body to her lips.
Once she reached her destination Brooke hovered her lips less than an inch away from Peyton’s, paused in that position for a couple of seconds, then just smiled wickedly and slid her tongue out over Peyton’s cheek. Brooke then began gently licking and kissing Peyton’s face, cleaning up almost all of Haley’s cum and pussy juice from her girlfriend’s pretty face. She would have got all of it but when Brooke was almost done Peyton captured Brooke’s lips with her own, making the head cheerleader completely forget what she was doing in favour of making out with the other girl on her squad.
The make out session lasted quite a while, Haley wondering if she should quietly leave and let her friends have the rest of the evening to snuggle. But before Haley could convince herself to get up Brooke broke the kiss, grinned and said, “You know what I want now baby?”
“Uh-huh, and I’m cool with it as long as Haley is.” Peyton replied with a soft smile.
“Don’t worry babe, you leave tutor girl to me.” Brooke grinned wickedly.
Brooke then looked over at Haley, stared at her for a few seconds, and then slowly crawled over to her, that wicked little grin of hers never leaving her face which worried Haley a little.
“W, w, what do you want?” Haley stammered.
“Don’t you worry your pretty little head tutor girl.” Brooke said, pausing to slide her tongue over Haley’s thigh, “Just give me a second to clean you up and I’ll tell you all about it.”
Haley wanted to insist that Brooke tell her now, but she was too busy softly moaning and whimpering as Brooke’s tongue slid all over first her right, then her left thigh, then her pussy lips. By the time Brooke’s tongue was sliding inside of her cunt again Haley didn’t care what Brooke wanted because she would give her anything if Brooke gave her more of this wonderful pleasure.
Sadly the pleasure didn’t last for long this time as once she was done cleaning up any left over cum from Haley’s pussy Brooke moved up to Haley’s face and clean that of Peyton’s cum. Having Brooke licking and kissing her face was a little weird, but Haley welcomed the kiss that followed it, the young tutor quickly becoming lost in her latest lesbian lip lock before Brooke broke it and grinned at her.
“You remember this, don’t you tutor girl?” Brooke questioned, reaching over slightly to grab the strap on dildo which was lying nearby and then holding it up in front of Haley’s face.
In response Haley nodded, gulped and then asked, “Are… are you going to fuck me with that?”
“I’d love too.” Brooke said, her eyes lighting up before then adding with a sigh, “But Peyton said if you agree to our little proposal we should save using toys on you for a different night. That way we don’t overwhelm you or whatever.”
“You know I’m right about that sweetie.” Peyton said as she finished tightening the other strap on cock Brooke got out around her waist.
“Maybe. But no toys for you doesn’t have to mean no toys. So, if you just want to relax and watch, or even go home, that’s cool. As you might remember, Peyton’s really good at fucking me with a strap on. But…” Brooke paused, and then suddenly sped up her words, “I always wanted to try a little DP action, so I was hoping you wouldn’t mind being one of the pieces of bread in a Brooke Davis sandwich. Just the bottom piece which doesn’t have too move around. Please?”
Despite Brooke talking quickly Haley heard everything the other girl said perfectly and found it intimidating and nerve wracking, and yet very exciting.
After a few long seconds of lip biting Haley replied with a soft, “Ok.”
Brooke beamed happily and said, “Lift your hips.”
Haley frowned for a moment, then blushed slightly as she realised why she needed to do that. It wasn’t as awkward as she thought it would be though. One moment Haley was lifting her hips and the next Brooke had strapped the cock around her waist and was greedily sucking on it.
Before Haley even got the chance to lower her head back down Brooke was bobbing her head on half of the dildo, and when Haley lowered her hips Brooke didn’t let the fake dick get away, the cheerleader captain making sure to keep the cock in her mouth the whole time.
Not long after that Brooke was allowing the head of the dick to slid down her throat so her lips could reach the base, the brunette cheerleader deep throating the big dildo with ease.
Haley had always tried to ignore the rumours about Brooke, or at least choose to believe those rumours were blown way out of proportion, but after watching her friend bob her head up and down the entire length of that big shaft it seemed pretty clear that the rumour about Brooke being the best cock sucker in Tree Hill must have been true. She was certainly better than Haley, and the young tutor couldn’t imagine how anyone could be better.
As if she was reading her thoughts Peyton suddenly said, “She’s a great cock sucker, isn’t she?”
“I, I guess.” Haley stammered.
Removing her mouth from the cock Brooke said in a more than slightly exaggerated offended tone, “You guess?”
“No, no I didn’t mean it like that. You’re an amazing cock sucker. The best ever. Really, I…” Haley rapidly replied, worried she had offended her friend.
“Relax tutor girl. Relax and breathe. I’m just messing with you.” Brooke reassured with a smile.
“Yeah, no need to tell Brooke how great she is at sucking cock.” Peyton said dryly, grinning at Brooke as she glared at her, “But sometimes it feels like she does seem to be reminded those aren’t the type of cocks which will give her a yummy treat if she keeps sucking on them long enough. Those are the type of cocks she just needs to get a little wet before fucking.”
“And suck clean after fucking.” Brooke added with a grin.
“True, but Haley’s cock is more than wet enough for your slutty little pussy, so if you don’t start taking that dick inside your hot little cunt soon then I’m going to go get some non-edible lube and cover my cock in it. That way you won’t get to suck my cock while riding Haley’s.” Peyton threatened softly.
“Spoilsport.” Brooke grumbled before splitting on Haley’s strap on dick and then quickly crawling up Haley’s body.
After positioning her pussy over the dildo Brooke reached down and grabbed the shaft, making sure it was firmly pressed against her wet and ready love hole before sliding down. She let out a long groan of pleasure as the first few inches of the strap on easily slid into her, Brooke waiting a few seconds as she enjoyed the initial penetration before slowly but surely sliding the rest of the way down.
“MMMMMMM, I’m ready for your cock now P Sawyer.” Brooke moaned, and then just to clarify added, “Bring it over here so I can suck it. Please? Please give me your big cock. I wanna suck on your big fat cock.”
“Well, only since you asked so nicely B Davis.” Peyton murmured, positioning herself so she was kneeling in front of Brooke with the dildo pressed only a few inches away from the other girl’s lips.
Brooke wasted no time in greedily swallowing the head of the fake cock, those soft lips of hers sliding up and down the shaft as, not for the first time, Peyton wished the cock was real.
Peyton was as happy with herself as she’d ever been. A big part of that was being with Brooke who made Peyton feel wanted, loved, and sexy in ways previous boyfriends never had. She had absolutely no real desire to be a boy, but Brooke was such a passionate and dedicated cock sucker that whenever Peyton found herself watching her girlfriend sucking on a dildo the blonde couldn’t help for the briefest of moments wish she could know what it was like for all those boys Brooke used to suck off.
These thoughts of course led Peyton to feelings of jealousy, which luckily quickly passed as she reminded herself that Brooke was hers now. Brooke Davis was now her girlfriend, just like Peyton had always secretly wanted her to be, and it didn’t matter how many cocks Brooke had sucked, or how many boys she had fucked, or even how many times she intended fucking Haley, because Brooke was hers and that’s all that mattered.
Of course if Peyton wanted to keep Brooke happy she would have to make sure to fulfil all her slutty little desires, which under the current situation was very, very easy.
“That’s it you dirty little slut, suck that cock!” Peyton said, hoping to fulfil her girlfriend’s desire for dirty talk, “Suck that cock you nasty little cock sucker! Suck it like you used to suck all those boys. Suck my cock while you’ve got Haley’s dick inside your slutty little cunt! Mmmmmmmm, yeah, take both those cocks like the slut you are!”
“Oh fuck yeah, I’m a slut. A nasty little cock sucking slut. A nasty, filthy little whore who loves taking two dicks inside her at the same fucking time!” Brooke moaned after she took the dildo out of her mouth and began gently jerking it up and down as if it was real, “Mmmmmm, I’m a dirty slutty whore who loves taking dick in her pussy and in her mouth at the same time. Oh yeah, I love the feeling of Haley’s big dick inside me as I suck your fucking cock Peyton!”
“Well why don’t you bounce on it baby? Why don’t you ride Haley’s cock while you’re sucking mine? Show me and Haley what kind of a slut you really are?” Peyton challenged.
“MMMMMmmmm yeah, gonna, ooooooooh, mmmmmmmmm, yeeeeessssssss, sooooooooo goooooodddddddd!” Brooke moaned shamelessly as she started bouncing up and down on Haley’s strap on dick.
Instead of concentrating on trying to say something coherent Brooke simply stuffed Peyton’s strap on back into her mouth and started giving that fake dick an even harder, wetter blow job.
Brooke salivated on the toy, allowing her saliva to drip out of her mouth and down the shaft only to catch up to her spit by sliding her lips all the way down the cock, taking the head of the man-made meat into her throat so she could get her lips wrapped around the base. She repeated this several times in between fucking her throat on Peyton’s cock, while she slammed her pussy up and down on Haley’s dick.
Being with two guys at once had always been one of Brooke’s hottest fantasies. Of course outsiders of being with Peyton threesomes in general were a big part of Brooke’s fantasies, whether it was boy-girl-girl, boy-girl-boy, or all girl. Living out her all girl fantasy had been amazing, with Peyton no less, and technically she still was, but equipping her girlfriend and friend with strap ons meant that Brooke was getting to fulfil her boy-girl-boy fantasies too.
Sucking on a cock while bouncing up and down on another was just as hot as Brooke had imagined it would be. Her pussy was so wet from watching Peyton and Haley go at it, and from going down on Peyton herself, but there was barely even any uncomfortableness when she took the dildo strapped around Haley’s waist inside her. And when she started moving up and down the pleasure had been incredible, and it had only got better with every bounce. The feeling of the cock in her mouth only heightened Brooke’s enjoyment, however as much as this was a dream come true there was another hole on her body she wanted Peyton to stick her cock in, a hole which would give Brooke a lot more pleasure when it was filled and fucked than her mouth.
So, after a long while of enjoying the feeling of cocks filling two holes, Brooke took her mouth off Peyton’s dick and moaned, “Please P Sawyer, fuck me too. MMMMMMMM, FUCK MY ASS! Oooooooh, fuck, ohhhhhhh, fuck my slutty little ass. AAAAHHHH, ohhhhhhh, fuck my butt hard and deep. Please, mmmmmmmmm, DP me, DP my slutty ass!”
“Sure, just let me go get the lube.” Peyton said, quickly moving off the bed.
“Awww, come on baby. I can’t wait that long.” Brooke whined, “Just shove that wet dick up my slutty ass. I’m so horny and your big dick is so wet it’ll just slide right in.”
“Maybe next time.” Peyton said, quickly grabbing a bottle of anal lubricant from out of one of her drawers and then returning to the bed.
Without needing to be asked Brooke had stopped bouncing, lent forward and stuck her ass out as far as she could to allow Peyton to lube and then shove her strap on in her ass. Clearly not content just wait around for Peyton to do that Brooke had also started kissing Haley, the perhaps now once innocent married girl happily kissing back with no hesitation whatsoever.
Peyton couldn’t help just watching the pretty sight for a few moments, her eyes darting back and forth between Brooke and Haley making out and her girlfriend’s inviting ass, before eventually kneeling down behind Brooke and beginning to cover her fingers in lubricant. Once they were well coated Peyton quickly pushed one of her fingers inside Brooke’s butt hole, the other girl moaning as the finger entered her back passage with ease.
“How does that feel baby?” Peyton asked curiously.
“Fucking amazing.” Brooke moaned as she quickly broke her kiss with Haley, “I can feel your finger rubbing against Haley’s cock. Mmmmmm, fuck, it’s almost like there’s nothing between them. And it feels so fucking goooooodddddd! But I want more. I want your cock in my ass. Mmmmmmm, please Peyton, stick that big fat cock up my fucking ass and fuck me. Ohhhhhh, I wanna get both my slutty fuck holes fucked sooooo bad!”
“Patients baby, just let me stretch your ass hole out a little first. Then I’ll fuck you. I promise.” Peyton said softly as she pumped her finger in and out of Brooke’s back door.
“Mmmmmm, hurry it up baby. Please, oooooooh, I wanna get double fucked!” Brooke moaned softly, loving the feeling of pleasure she was getting from the finger fucking, even if it wasn’t stretching her ass as much as she would have liked.
Peyton did start stretching Brooke’s ass a lot more though as she added first a second finger, then a third, and then finally a fourth, twisting them around inside the brunette’s butt as she thrust these fingers in and out of her back passage. With each and every additional finger Brooke moaned in pleasure, and while Peyton knew her girlfriend well enough to tell when she was hiding a little pain and discomfort the blonde also knew from past experience the pleasure Brooke was receiving far outweighed anything else. However this wasn’t exactly like all the other times she had fucked Brooke’s ass, so Peyton was in no hurry.
Besides, it wasn’t like Peyton wasn’t used to ignoring Brooke’s begging. She did it all the time, and Peyton knew while Brooke might claim to hate it it made the eventual pleasure of getting what she wanted all the sweeter.
So Peyton took her time finger fucking Brooke’s ass, switching between slow thrusts to pounding her fingers in and out of her girlfriend’s butt hole, sometimes gently twisting and curling those fingers inside Brooke’s bowels while at other times moving around inside the other girl’s rectum as hard and as fast as she could. Peyton finger fucked Brooke’s butt until she thought her girlfriend was ready to take her strap on cock up her ass. Then she anally finger fucked Brooke some more, wanting Brooke to be practically desperate to get that fake cock in her ass before she actually gave it to her.
Eventually Peyton felt Brooke’s begging had become desperate enough so she quickly pulled her fingers out and replace them with her strap on after she had used her left hand to squirt a little lube all over it. Once the head of the dildo was pressed firmly against Brooke’s butt hole Peyton asked, “You want this cock in your ass baby?”
“OHHHH YES! GIVE ME THAT BIG COCK! SHOVE YOUR BIG COCK UP MY ASS P SAWYER OOOOOOOHHHHHHHHH!” Brooke cried out joyfully as she felt the dildo finally pushing through her ass hole, “Oooooooooohhhhhhhh yeeeeeesssssss mmmmmmmmmm, fuck me. Oh Peyton, fuck my ass.”
Brooke sighed in relief as she felt her butt hole snapping closed around the head of the large cock. She then moaned joyfully as her greedy back door swallowed inch after inch of dildo with ease, Brooke experiencing no pain whatsoever as the first few inches entered her rectum. Taking the rest of the strap on wasn’t quite as easy, but the pain was minimal.
It always had been for Brooke. Ever since she had lost her anal cherry Brooke had found she could take a nice big dildo up her butt just as easily as she could take it in her pussy, and taking it in the ass made her feel like such a dirty little slut she often preferred anal. Sure, there were times Peyton would make love to her pussy with a strap on which was so amazing Brooke would literally be brought to tears with the pleasure, passion and love she felt, but this wasn’t about making love. This was about naughty, slutty, three-way lesbian sex, and Brooke intended to enjoy it.